Spigen Tough Armor vs Otterbox Defender Review: Which Phone Case Delivers the Best Protection?

Spigen Tough Armor vs Otterbox Defender Review: Which Phone Case Delivers the Best Protection?

As the cost of replacing phones has increased substantially over the past few years, many people are looking for a phone case that will provide the best protection for the most expensive accessory they bring everywhere.  Breaking your $1000+ phone is a quick way to ruin your day and put a dent in your bank account.  That’s one of the main reasons that protection is one of the key attributes that people look for in a phone case.  There are many options available that purport to be a full protection case, but two of the best options are the Spigen Tough Armor and the Otterbox Defender.  We put together a review of these two popular cases to help you decide which phone case delivers the best value and protection for you.

Spigen Tough Armor

If you decide to use a truly protective phone case, you will have to accept some bulkiness.  Many people do stay away from a protective phone case, because of how much larger it makes their phone.  This is one of the main reasons you would want to start your search for a protective phone case with the Spigen Tough Armor.

For the amount of protection it provides your phone, the Spigen Tough Armor is actually pretty sleek.  It is larger than a standard plastic phone case, but it has to be in order to provide solid protection.  The unique Air Cushion Technology and polycarbonate back provide a sturdy cover for your phone without adding much weight or size.  You will certainly notice the difference between holding the phone by itself and adding the Spigen Tough Armor.  However, most users report getting used to the added size quickly.

Spigen Tough Armor has models for nearly every iPhone, Samsung, and Android phone.  The Spigen Tough Armor for iPhone X starts at $15.99 on Amazon right now so it’s affordable as well.  It supports wireless charging on the iPhone X and Samsung phones that offer that feature, unlike some protective cases that can cause issues with that feature.  The case is designed to be screen less for newer phones like the iPhone x so you would need to add their tempered glass screen protector in order to have full protection for your new phone.

Otterbox Defender

The Otterbox Defender series was redesigned to be screen less for the iPhone X.  While the retail price is $49.95, you can currently purchase it new on Amazon for $23.  Since it’s only slightly more expensive than the Spigen Tough Armor, price will probably not be the determining factor in your decision between these two phone cases.

The first thing you will notice about the Otterbox Defender is that it is bulkier than the Spigen Tough Armor.  Otterbox has always made some of the largest phone cases by design.  They advertise them as the best protective cases and a part of that is their size.  The Defender series for iPhone X has been noticeably trimmed down from some past models though.  Removing the screen protector is a part of the slimmer look so you would want to add their Alpha Glass for full protection, but they also did a great job of redesigning the rest of the cover as well.  The solid inner core combined with a soft outer slipcover still provides great protection when you drop your phone without feeling like you are carrying around a brick phone from the early 90s.  They have significantly improved the access to all buttons on the phone and the port cover is much easier to remove than past models.

Otterbox always gets fantastic reviews as a company.  They provide excellent customer service if you ever have an issue with any of their products.  You also get a lifetime warranty on their cases.  There are some limitations on what lifetime actually means, but most customers report receiving no hassles if their case breaks a year or two down the road and they need to exchange it for a new one.

Which Phone Case is Right for You?

If protection is your most important priority for a phone case, then you can’t go wrong with either of these options.  They both provide significantly more protection than your average phone case.  The Otterbox Defender provides such a snug fit to your phone that many users actually report having trouble taking it off when they want to clean their phone.  You can decide for yourself whether that is actually a good thing.  The Spigen Tough Armor has a sleeker design and it’s about 30% cheaper so most people will probably prefer it.  They both receive fantastic reviews on every site they are sold on so you can be fairly confident that you will get a phone case that provides great protection.  The Spigen Tough Armor is just a slightly better case for everyday use.  The Otterbox Defender is probably a better choice if you expect your phone to take a regular beating or you have a job that involves a lot of dust or dirt.

About The Author

dkoernke